{
  "record_id": "GOBLIN-HELD-HISTORY-2026-10-27-001",
  "title": "When the Crowd Gives a Cart Back",
  "status": "EXPLORATORY_FINITE_MECHANISM_INTERVENTION_NO_MODEL_AGENTS",
  "selection_note": "These are transparent selected witnesses, not representative samples. Both display selections made after the grid are identified below.",
  "stores": [
    {
      "id": "moth",
      "name": "Mothlight Market"
    },
    {
      "id": "copper",
      "name": "Copper Commons"
    },
    {
      "id": "gold",
      "name": "Golden Goblin Goods"
    },
    {
      "id": "lantern",
      "name": "Lantern & Nail"
    },
    {
      "id": "stone",
      "name": "Stone & Star"
    },
    {
      "id": "duck",
      "name": "Duck Cart Co."
    }
  ],
  "witnesses": [
    {
      "seed": 4,
      "budget": 3,
      "cohort": "mixed",
      "reverse": false,
      "comparisons": {
        "live": {
          "changed_choices": 1,
          "changed_paths": 4,
          "changed_first": 4,
          "changed_ids": [
            6
          ],
          "strict_nonvisitor_ids": [],
          "no_treatment_target_visit_ids": [],
          "target_open_gain": 4,
          "target_choices": [
            0,
            0
          ],
          "paired_zero_sale": true,
          "ghost": true
        },
        "held": {
          "changed_choices": 2,
          "changed_paths": 5,
          "changed_first": 5,
          "changed_ids": [
            6,
            16
          ],
          "strict_nonvisitor_ids": [],
          "no_treatment_target_visit_ids": [],
          "target_open_gain": 5,
          "target_choices": [
            0,
            0
          ],
          "paired_zero_sale": true,
          "ghost": true
        },
        "off": {
          "changed_choices": 3,
          "changed_paths": 11,
          "changed_first": 9,
          "changed_ids": [
            6,
            20,
            23
          ],
          "strict_nonvisitor_ids": [],
          "no_treatment_target_visit_ids": [],
          "target_open_gain": 11,
          "target_choices": [
            0,
            0
          ],
          "paired_zero_sale": true,
          "ghost": true
        }
      },
      "overlap": {
        "live_only": [],
        "held_only": [
          16
        ],
        "both_same_destination": [
          6
        ],
        "both_different_destination": [],
        "neither": [
          1,
          2,
          3,
          4,
          5,
          7,
          8,
          9,
          10,
          11,
          12,
          13,
          14,
          15,
          17,
          18,
          19,
          20,
          21,
          22,
          23,
          24
        ],
        "live_vs_held_changed": [
          16
        ]
      },
      "live_minus_held_changed_choices": -1,
      "id": "suppression",
      "selection_rule": "First primary-panel cell with fewer changed choices under live feedback than held history, in fixed seed/budget/roster/arrival loop order.",
      "selection_status": "Specified in protocol before new-grid execution",
      "world_totals": {
        "base": {
          "traffic": [
            21,
            2,
            1,
            22,
            5,
            21
          ],
          "first": [
            6,
            1,
            0,
            5,
            2,
            10
          ],
          "carts": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            7,
            2,
            15
          ]
        },
        "live": {
          "traffic": [
            20,
            2,
            5,
            20,
            5,
            20
          ],
          "first": [
            5,
            1,
            4,
            5,
            2,
            7
          ],
          "carts": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            8,
            2,
            14
          ]
        },
        "held": {
          "traffic": [
            20,
            2,
            6,
            19,
            5,
            20
          ],
          "first": [
            5,
            1,
            5,
            4,
            2,
            7
          ],
          "carts": [
            0,
            1,
            0,
            7,
            2,
            14
          ]
        },
        "off_base": {
          "traffic": [
            18,
            5,
            0,
            16,
            10,
            23
          ],
          "first": [
            5,
            2,
            0,
            4,
            5,
            8
          ],
          "carts": [
            0,
            3,
            0,
            2,
            4,
            15
          ]
        },
        "off_promoted": {
          "traffic": [
            15,
            3,
            11,
            15,
            7,
            21
          ],
          "first": [
            4,
            1,
            9,
            4,
            4,
            2
          ],
          "carts": [
            0,
            3,
            0,
            3,
            4,
            14
          ]
        }
      },
      "shoppers": [
        {
          "id": 1,
          "type": "Reliability",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 2,
          "type": "Budget",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 3,
          "type": "Evidence",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 4,
          "type": "Wanderer",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 5,
          "type": "Crowd",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 6,
          "type": "Copy",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": true,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 7,
          "type": "Reliability",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "copper",
              "lantern",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "copper",
              "lantern",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 8,
          "type": "Budget",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 9,
          "type": "Evidence",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 10,
          "type": "Wanderer",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "copper",
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "copper",
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "copper",
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 11,
          "type": "Crowd",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "copper",
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 12,
          "type": "Copy",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "lantern",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "lantern",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "lantern",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 13,
          "type": "Reliability",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "copper",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "copper",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 14,
          "type": "Budget",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "duck",
              "gold"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 15,
          "type": "Evidence",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "stone",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "stone",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "stone",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "stone",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "stone",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 16,
          "type": "Wanderer",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "copper",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "copper",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "copper",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": true,
          "held_vs_live_changed": true
        },
        {
          "id": 17,
          "type": "Crowd",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 18,
          "type": "Copy",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 19,
          "type": "Reliability",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 20,
          "type": "Budget",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 21,
          "type": "Evidence",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 22,
          "type": "Wanderer",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern",
              "gold"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern",
              "gold"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern",
              "gold"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 23,
          "type": "Crowd",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "lantern",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 24,
          "type": "Copy",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "seed": 72,
      "budget": 2,
      "cohort": "mixed",
      "reverse": false,
      "comparisons": {
        "live": {
          "changed_choices": 16,
          "changed_paths": 16,
          "changed_first": 8,
          "changed_ids": [
            2,
            5,
            6,
            8,
            9,
            11,
            12,
            14,
            16,
            17,
            18,
            19,
            20,
            22,
            23,
            24
          ],
          "strict_nonvisitor_ids": [
            8,
            9,
            16,
            19,
            22
          ],
          "no_treatment_target_visit_ids": [
            8,
            9,
            16,
            19,
            22
          ],
          "target_open_gain": 11,
          "target_choices": [
            0,
            0
          ],
          "paired_zero_sale": true,
          "ghost": true
        },
        "held": {
          "changed_choices": 3,
          "changed_paths": 5,
          "changed_first": 4,
          "changed_ids": [
            2,
            6,
            24
          ],
          "strict_nonvisitor_ids": [],
          "no_treatment_target_visit_ids": [],
          "target_open_gain": 5,
          "target_choices": [
            0,
            0
          ],
          "paired_zero_sale": true,
          "ghost": true
        },
        "off": {
          "changed_choices": 4,
          "changed_paths": 10,
          "changed_first": 8,
          "changed_ids": [
            2,
            5,
            14,
            24
          ],
          "strict_nonvisitor_ids": [],
          "no_treatment_target_visit_ids": [],
          "target_open_gain": 10,
          "target_choices": [
            0,
            0
          ],
          "paired_zero_sale": true,
          "ghost": true
        }
      },
      "overlap": {
        "live_only": [
          5,
          8,
          9,
          11,
          12,
          14,
          16,
          17,
          18,
          19,
          20,
          22,
          23
        ],
        "held_only": [],
        "both_same_destination": [
          2,
          6,
          24
        ],
        "both_different_destination": [],
        "neither": [
          1,
          3,
          4,
          7,
          10,
          13,
          15,
          21
        ],
        "live_vs_held_changed": [
          5,
          8,
          9,
          11,
          12,
          14,
          16,
          17,
          18,
          19,
          20,
          22,
          23
        ]
      },
      "live_minus_held_changed_choices": 13,
      "id": "parent_case",
      "selection_rule": "Original post-hoc extreme parent example, selected before this mechanism follow-up.",
      "selection_status": "Previously post-hoc selected parent example",
      "world_totals": {
        "base": {
          "traffic": [
            23,
            3,
            0,
            7,
            3,
            12
          ],
          "first": [
            13,
            1,
            0,
            5,
            0,
            5
          ],
          "carts": [
            1,
            3,
            0,
            5,
            3,
            12
          ]
        },
        "live": {
          "traffic": [
            21,
            5,
            11,
            6,
            3,
            2
          ],
          "first": [
            12,
            2,
            5,
            5,
            0,
            0
          ],
          "carts": [
            11,
            5,
            0,
            3,
            3,
            2
          ]
        },
        "held": {
          "traffic": [
            21,
            3,
            5,
            7,
            2,
            10
          ],
          "first": [
            10,
            1,
            4,
            5,
            0,
            4
          ],
          "carts": [
            4,
            3,
            0,
            5,
            2,
            10
          ]
        },
        "off_base": {
          "traffic": [
            15,
            4,
            0,
            8,
            8,
            13
          ],
          "first": [
            6,
            2,
            0,
            6,
            1,
            9
          ],
          "carts": [
            1,
            4,
            0,
            4,
            7,
            8
          ]
        },
        "off_promoted": {
          "traffic": [
            12,
            4,
            10,
            6,
            4,
            12
          ],
          "first": [
            5,
            2,
            8,
            4,
            0,
            5
          ],
          "carts": [
            4,
            4,
            0,
            4,
            4,
            8
          ]
        }
      },
      "shoppers": [
        {
          "id": 1,
          "type": "Reliability",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "copper",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "copper",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "copper",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "copper",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "copper",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 2,
          "type": "Budget",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "gold"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "gold"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "gold"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": true,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 3,
          "type": "Evidence",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 4,
          "type": "Wanderer",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 5,
          "type": "Crowd",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "gold"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": true
        },
        {
          "id": 6,
          "type": "Copy",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": true,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 7,
          "type": "Reliability",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 8,
          "type": "Budget",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": true
        },
        {
          "id": 9,
          "type": "Evidence",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "copper",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": true
        },
        {
          "id": 10,
          "type": "Wanderer",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 11,
          "type": "Crowd",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "gold"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": true
        },
        {
          "id": 12,
          "type": "Copy",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": true
        },
        {
          "id": 13,
          "type": "Reliability",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 14,
          "type": "Budget",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "gold"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "gold"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": true
        },
        {
          "id": 15,
          "type": "Evidence",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 16,
          "type": "Wanderer",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": true
        },
        {
          "id": 17,
          "type": "Crowd",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "gold"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": true
        },
        {
          "id": 18,
          "type": "Copy",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": true
        },
        {
          "id": 19,
          "type": "Reliability",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "copper",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "copper",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": true
        },
        {
          "id": 20,
          "type": "Budget",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": true
        },
        {
          "id": 21,
          "type": "Evidence",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 22,
          "type": "Wanderer",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": true
        },
        {
          "id": 23,
          "type": "Crowd",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "gold"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": true
        },
        {
          "id": 24,
          "type": "Copy",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": true,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "seed": 7,
      "budget": 2,
      "cohort": "mixed",
      "reverse": true,
      "comparisons": {
        "live": {
          "changed_choices": 1,
          "changed_paths": 14,
          "changed_first": 9,
          "changed_ids": [
            2
          ],
          "strict_nonvisitor_ids": [],
          "no_treatment_target_visit_ids": [],
          "target_open_gain": 12,
          "target_choices": [
            0,
            0
          ],
          "paired_zero_sale": true,
          "ghost": true
        },
        "held": {
          "changed_choices": 1,
          "changed_paths": 4,
          "changed_first": 4,
          "changed_ids": [
            18
          ],
          "strict_nonvisitor_ids": [],
          "no_treatment_target_visit_ids": [],
          "target_open_gain": 4,
          "target_choices": [
            0,
            0
          ],
          "paired_zero_sale": true,
          "ghost": true
        },
        "off": {
          "changed_choices": 3,
          "changed_paths": 9,
          "changed_first": 7,
          "changed_ids": [
            11,
            18,
            23
          ],
          "strict_nonvisitor_ids": [],
          "no_treatment_target_visit_ids": [],
          "target_open_gain": 9,
          "target_choices": [
            0,
            0
          ],
          "paired_zero_sale": true,
          "ghost": true
        }
      },
      "overlap": {
        "live_only": [
          2
        ],
        "held_only": [
          18
        ],
        "both_same_destination": [],
        "both_different_destination": [],
        "neither": [
          1,
          3,
          4,
          5,
          6,
          7,
          8,
          9,
          10,
          11,
          12,
          13,
          14,
          15,
          16,
          17,
          19,
          20,
          21,
          22,
          23,
          24
        ],
        "live_vs_held_changed": [
          2,
          18
        ]
      },
      "live_minus_held_changed_choices": 0,
      "id": "equal_count_different_choices",
      "selection_rule": "First primary-panel cell with equal changed-choice counts but different live/held shopper choices, in fixed loop order.",
      "selection_status": "Post-hoc display selection from the completed fixed grid; aggregate metric was specified before execution",
      "world_totals": {
        "base": {
          "traffic": [
            19,
            1,
            0,
            9,
            1,
            18
          ],
          "first": [
            10,
            0,
            0,
            3,
            0,
            11
          ],
          "carts": [
            0,
            1,
            0,
            7,
            0,
            16
          ]
        },
        "live": {
          "traffic": [
            9,
            1,
            12,
            8,
            1,
            17
          ],
          "first": [
            7,
            0,
            7,
            2,
            0,
            8
          ],
          "carts": [
            1,
            1,
            0,
            7,
            0,
            15
          ]
        },
        "held": {
          "traffic": [
            16,
            1,
            4,
            9,
            1,
            17
          ],
          "first": [
            8,
            0,
            4,
            3,
            0,
            9
          ],
          "carts": [
            1,
            1,
            0,
            7,
            0,
            15
          ]
        },
        "off_base": {
          "traffic": [
            17,
            3,
            0,
            10,
            4,
            14
          ],
          "first": [
            11,
            1,
            0,
            2,
            2,
            8
          ],
          "carts": [
            1,
            2,
            0,
            6,
            2,
            13
          ]
        },
        "off_promoted": {
          "traffic": [
            12,
            2,
            9,
            10,
            4,
            11
          ],
          "first": [
            7,
            1,
            7,
            2,
            2,
            5
          ],
          "carts": [
            3,
            2,
            0,
            7,
            2,
            10
          ]
        }
      },
      "shoppers": [
        {
          "id": 1,
          "type": "Reliability",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 2,
          "type": "Budget",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "gold"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": true
        },
        {
          "id": 3,
          "type": "Evidence",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 4,
          "type": "Wanderer",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 5,
          "type": "Crowd",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "gold"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 6,
          "type": "Copy",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 7,
          "type": "Reliability",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "copper",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "copper",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 8,
          "type": "Budget",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "gold"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "gold"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 9,
          "type": "Evidence",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 10,
          "type": "Wanderer",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 11,
          "type": "Crowd",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "gold"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 12,
          "type": "Copy",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 13,
          "type": "Reliability",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 14,
          "type": "Budget",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "gold"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 15,
          "type": "Evidence",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 16,
          "type": "Wanderer",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 17,
          "type": "Crowd",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 18,
          "type": "Copy",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": true,
          "held_vs_live_changed": true
        },
        {
          "id": 19,
          "type": "Reliability",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 20,
          "type": "Budget",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "gold"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 21,
          "type": "Evidence",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 22,
          "type": "Wanderer",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 23,
          "type": "Crowd",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 24,
          "type": "Copy",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "seed": 86,
      "budget": 2,
      "cohort": "mixed",
      "reverse": true,
      "comparisons": {
        "live": {
          "changed_choices": 6,
          "changed_paths": 14,
          "changed_first": 13,
          "changed_ids": [
            5,
            6,
            8,
            9,
            14,
            20
          ],
          "strict_nonvisitor_ids": [
            9
          ],
          "no_treatment_target_visit_ids": [
            9
          ],
          "target_open_gain": 11,
          "target_choices": [
            0,
            1
          ],
          "paired_zero_sale": false,
          "ghost": false
        },
        "held": {
          "changed_choices": 2,
          "changed_paths": 5,
          "changed_first": 4,
          "changed_ids": [
            6,
            12
          ],
          "strict_nonvisitor_ids": [],
          "no_treatment_target_visit_ids": [],
          "target_open_gain": 5,
          "target_choices": [
            0,
            0
          ],
          "paired_zero_sale": true,
          "ghost": true
        },
        "off": {
          "changed_choices": 3,
          "changed_paths": 10,
          "changed_first": 9,
          "changed_ids": [
            6,
            11,
            23
          ],
          "strict_nonvisitor_ids": [],
          "no_treatment_target_visit_ids": [],
          "target_open_gain": 10,
          "target_choices": [
            0,
            0
          ],
          "paired_zero_sale": true,
          "ghost": true
        }
      },
      "overlap": {
        "live_only": [
          5,
          8,
          9,
          14,
          20
        ],
        "held_only": [
          12
        ],
        "both_same_destination": [
          6
        ],
        "both_different_destination": [],
        "neither": [
          1,
          2,
          3,
          4,
          7,
          10,
          11,
          13,
          15,
          16,
          17,
          18,
          19,
          21,
          22,
          23,
          24
        ],
        "live_vs_held_changed": [
          5,
          8,
          9,
          12,
          14,
          20
        ]
      },
      "live_minus_held_changed_choices": 4,
      "id": "nonzero_target",
      "selection_rule": "First primary-panel cell failing the paired zero-sale condition under live feedback, in fixed loop order.",
      "selection_status": "Post-hoc display selection from the completed fixed grid; inclusion in denominators was specified before execution",
      "world_totals": {
        "base": {
          "traffic": [
            22,
            2,
            0,
            15,
            2,
            7
          ],
          "first": [
            16,
            1,
            0,
            7,
            0,
            0
          ],
          "carts": [
            3,
            1,
            0,
            12,
            1,
            7
          ]
        },
        "live": {
          "traffic": [
            14,
            0,
            11,
            13,
            3,
            7
          ],
          "first": [
            7,
            0,
            11,
            5,
            0,
            1
          ],
          "carts": [
            2,
            0,
            1,
            12,
            2,
            7
          ]
        },
        "held": {
          "traffic": [
            19,
            2,
            5,
            14,
            2,
            6
          ],
          "first": [
            12,
            1,
            4,
            7,
            0,
            0
          ],
          "carts": [
            5,
            1,
            0,
            11,
            1,
            6
          ]
        },
        "off_base": {
          "traffic": [
            10,
            5,
            0,
            14,
            7,
            12
          ],
          "first": [
            7,
            0,
            0,
            6,
            3,
            8
          ],
          "carts": [
            1,
            4,
            0,
            7,
            4,
            8
          ]
        },
        "off_promoted": {
          "traffic": [
            7,
            4,
            10,
            11,
            6,
            10
          ],
          "first": [
            4,
            0,
            9,
            4,
            3,
            4
          ],
          "carts": [
            2,
            4,
            0,
            7,
            3,
            8
          ]
        }
      },
      "shoppers": [
        {
          "id": 1,
          "type": "Reliability",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 2,
          "type": "Budget",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 3,
          "type": "Evidence",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 4,
          "type": "Wanderer",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 5,
          "type": "Crowd",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": true
        },
        {
          "id": 6,
          "type": "Copy",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": true,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 7,
          "type": "Reliability",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 8,
          "type": "Budget",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "gold"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": true
        },
        {
          "id": 9,
          "type": "Evidence",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": true
        },
        {
          "id": 10,
          "type": "Wanderer",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "copper",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "copper",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 11,
          "type": "Crowd",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 12,
          "type": "Copy",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": true,
          "held_vs_live_changed": true
        },
        {
          "id": 13,
          "type": "Reliability",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 14,
          "type": "Budget",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": true
        },
        {
          "id": 15,
          "type": "Evidence",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 16,
          "type": "Wanderer",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 17,
          "type": "Crowd",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 18,
          "type": "Copy",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 19,
          "type": "Reliability",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "copper"
            ],
            "selected": "copper"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 20,
          "type": "Budget",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "moth"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "live_changed": true,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": true
        },
        {
          "id": 21,
          "type": "Evidence",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "stone",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 22,
          "type": "Wanderer",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "duck"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 23,
          "type": "Crowd",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "moth"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "lantern",
              "gold"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "stone"
            ],
            "selected": "stone"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "duck",
              "gold"
            ],
            "selected": "duck"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        },
        {
          "id": 24,
          "type": "Copy",
          "neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "held": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_neutral": {
            "opens": [
              "moth",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "off_promoted": {
            "opens": [
              "gold",
              "lantern"
            ],
            "selected": "lantern"
          },
          "live_changed": false,
          "held_changed": false,
          "held_vs_live_changed": false
        }
      ]
    }
  ]
}